ridership

TransitMatters Executive Director's Public Comment At July MBTA Board Meeting

Below is the full transcript of the public comments our Executive Director, Jarred Johnson, presented to the MBTA Board on July 27, 2023:

“Good morning, Secretary Fiandaca, Chair Glynn, General Manager Eng, members of the board, and staff. I appreciate the opportunity to provide public comment.

My name is Jarred Johnson, with TransitMatters.

I want to talk about restoring public trust in the agency and fighting for riders. Confidence in the agency is at an all-time low and the agency’s actions, or lack thereof, are only eroding further and making the job of advocates more difficult.

The T is not doing a good enough job of demonstrating its care for riders. Ridership and service quality should be on the same level as safety. Lest my comments be misinterpreted, this does not mean that safety should be at all compromised. This means the T needs to raise ridership and service quality up to that level. This means attracting and retaining ridership must become a key priority. The T's quite frankly offensive posture towards riders has been disappointing, to say the least.

The recent Green Line Central Subway shutdown with less than 48 hours notice and no public information about what work was being done is not acceptable. I even spoke with an operator who told me they often find out about these diversions in the press along with riders. There is often incorrect signage and poor communication during these diversions. This is compounded by poor operations and inconsistent practices on the portions of the rapid transit network where service is running.

We must address the lack of transparency and accountability. Why is the Orange Line 10 minutes slower today than before the Sept 2022 shutdown? Who will be held responsible for the falsified or incomplete information that led to the global slowdown this past winter?

The story coming out of the Sumner Tunnel shutdown can’t be that the T bent over backward to help drivers with better information, free bus and Blue Line fares, and cheap Commuter Rail fares and then just stopped when it was over.

I wake up every day thinking about how to make the MBTA and how I can help. And in addition to my staff, I lead a team of volunteers who do the same without pay. I know MBTA staff wake up every day trying to run safe service, solve problems, and plan for the future. It’s disheartening to not see more of a visible change in how this agency operates. Leadership isn’t being vocal or transparent enough about how the agency is fighting for riders.

Riders have endured years of acute crisis and decades of underfunding and managed decline. This isn’t about ascribing fault to someone, but this board and this leadership team is responsible now. Seven months is too long to not know when the Red Line’s travel times will be back to normal. It’s too long not to have a timeline for returning rapid transit headways back to pre-pandemic levels. It’s too long to not have set a firm timeline for having enough bus operators to start Phase I or the Bus Network Redesign.

We don’t have time for the T to get all of its ducks in a row before improving its communication and taking action to improve service quality. People are making major life decisions based on the poor quality of today’s service and the lack of information about when it will get better. People are considering whether they’ll buy a car, or whether they’ll take a job in Atlanta. Companies are making siting decisions based on whether they believe the T will get better.

The T has a proud history and was one of the best agencies in the country if not the world. There’s an anecdote about just how good the T used to be: in the 80s there was an award competition that banned the T from competing for a few years because they won too many times in a row. We can get back there, but we’re missing the vision to make that happen. Failure is not an option, because the T is essential to the region’s future. The T is critical to addressing climate change, congestion, housing, socioeconomic equity and so much more.

I’m urging this agency to show a marked change in how it communicates with riders and to start delivering real meaningful results that change the perception of the system.

Thank you.”

TransitMatters Executive Director's Public Comment at March MBTA Board Meeting

Below is the full transcript of the public comments our Executive Director, Jarred Johnson, presented to the MBTA Board via voicemail on March 23, 2023:

“Hello, my name is Jarred Johnson and I'm the Executive Director of TransitMatters. Madam Secretary, Madame Chair, General Manager, and members of the Board and staff, thank you for the opportunity to provide for the common. And please excuse my bluntness.

This Board is failing riders, full stop. I want to start by saying that I appreciate and understand the amount of time that you all have given over the past year and a half. I know that this role is not easy; however, neither is being a T rider these days.

The system is in crisis, but you would not know that by watching a Board meeting. It has been incredibly frustrating to read about escalator safety experts or staff in charge of hiring dispatchers appearing before the board and receiving no questions from you all. Or to learn about the FTA engagement from the Globe. The previous Board used to be a forum for riders to voice their concerns and be heard as well as for the board to dig into the issues facing the agency.

I understood that this board wanted to do things differently, and I defended this in the press. I understood that the previous amount of public comment and engagement with staff was not sustainable, but the pendulum has swung too far. I don’t think anyone would suggest that the hands off approach has been successful.

Giving public comment to this board is largely seen as talking to a brick wall by advocates, and I'm not sure most riders even know the T has a board. Furthermore, we are a year and a half past the end of the State of Emergency, it's time to make this meeting hybrid. Not allowing live comment—either in person, on Zoom, or over the phone—is another roadblock for meaningful engagement.

I must also address the patently offensive comments about T ridership and a "new normal.” We're seeing ridership reach pre-pandemic levels in NYC. The stagnant ridership at the MBTA is a clear reflection of perceptions of safety, poor reliability, service cuts, slow zones, and painful diversions. We are nearly 9 months into service cuts on rapid transit and more than a year into bus service cuts. This Board needs a laser focus on hiring and service quality, not talk that reeks of managed decline.

I'm appealing to you all, because I know you care, but from the outside that is far from evident. I didn't want to have to be so blunt, but the Board has had zero engagement with advocates, including ignoring welcome letters. This is an agency in crisis and riders and employees—especially frontline employees who bear the brunt of frustration from upset riders—deserve better.

I look forward to actual engagement with riders and advocates. And to a new Board culture. Thank you for your time.”

For media inquiries, please e-mail media@transitmatters.org

###

The Case Against MBTA Fare Increases—And How to Move Forward

The Case Against MBTA Fare Increases—And How to Move Forward

The MBTA fare increase proposals (presentation, summary) are unnecessary and not even helpful in closing the budget gap. We summarized all the feedback we've received and proposed alternatives to increase ridership and revenue and reduce operating costs.